This stamp is reserved for games that are still as enjoyable now as they were the the first time you played them.
Bomb.
If you see this stamp, it means the game terrible. It was boring. It was just plain bad. However you want to say it, this is the worst of the worst for the NES.
Developed by the Devil.
If we contemplated mass murder at any point during the game, we gave it this stamp.
Amazing Multiplayer.
You're not seriously considering going into River City alone, are you? If a game has this stamp, it means you better bring a friend for the full experience.
Best Bosses.
A game will get this stamp if its bosses were cool, memorable, or just plain fun to fight.
Terrific Tunes.
If you are still humming the game's music while you sleep, then the game deserves this stamp.
Crappy Cover Art.
If the art on the cover is totally misleading (see: Mega Man), totally outlandish (see: Mega Man) or just plain awful (see: Mega Man), it deserves this stamp.
Praiseworthy Puzzles.
The NES had a lot of puzzle games, but not all were great. This stamp denotes the cream of the crop.